Painting or replacing cabinet doors is a choice between keeping a familiar profile and changing the design. A freshly painted kitchen can still feel dated if the door style is the part you wanted to change. An arched panel becomes a freshly painted arched panel. Deep mouldings and wide frames remain visible, even under a different colour.
Refinishing can be a good investment when you like your existing doors and want a new finish. But if you are hoping for a different profile, compare the cost of replacement doors before committing to repainting the old ones.
For Toronto and GTA homeowners with suitable cabinet boxes, that comparison opens up another option: keep the cabinetry that works, refinish the visible boxes where needed, and fit new doors and drawer fronts in a style you actually want.
Miter5 manufactures the replacement fronts. Your refinishing or installation contractor can coordinate the cabinet-box work, fitting and finish matching as part of the complete kitchen update.
Would you like the same doors in a different colour?
Start with this question before choosing paint samples. Picture your existing doors in the colour you have in mind. Do you still like the curve of the panel, the width of the frame and the depth of the detailing?
If the answer is yes, refinishing may give you the change you need. Sound doors with a profile that suits the room do not need replacing simply because the finish is worn or the colour no longer works.
If you keep returning to photographs of thin Shaker, straight-lined Shaker or smooth slab fronts, however, repainting an older cathedral or heavily moulded door will leave you with a different result. Paint changes the surface finish; it does not turn that profile into the one you have chosen.
There is no rule that an older style must go. The useful test is whether you want to keep it.

What changes when you replace the fronts?
Replacement doors let you choose a new profile as well as a colour. Matching drawer fronts help carry the same design across the kitchen, rather than combining new doors with drawers that still show the old detailing.
Made-to-size fronts can be specified for the existing cabinetry, subject to confirming the finished dimensions and hardware requirements. The cabinet boxes, room layout and countertops can remain where suitable. Visible frames, end panels, fillers, trim and toe kicks may still need refinishing or another agreed treatment to coordinate with the new fronts.
Changing the fronts does not correct a poor layout or repair damaged cabinet boxes. Check that the retained cabinetry is worth keeping before investing in either option. Our guide to replacing cabinet doors and drawer fronts explains the broader replacement approach.
Four examples of changing the style instead of repainting it
An older arched or heavily detailed door can be painted in a new colour, but its shape will remain. Replacement gives you a choice of a different design. These Miter5 profiles show how that choice could change the appearance of your kitchen:

Aria vertical-groove slab cabinet doors: a slab face with routed vertical grooves for a kitchen where you want linear detail instead of an older arched panel.

Aurora Shaker cabinet doors: a straight-lined frame and recessed centre with a subtle inside bevel, offering a different outline from an arched panel.

Palmerston thin Shaker cabinet doors: a recessed centre panel with narrow 3/4-inch rails and stiles and square corners, offering a slimmer Shaker profile for homeowners who want to move away from an older arched door.

Euclid architectural raised-panel cabinet doors: a defined raised-panel design for a kitchen where you want to retain depth and detail while choosing a new profile.
Each linked page shows the door style and its calculator, so you can compare the design and estimate the price for your finished sizes. View the profiles alongside your countertops, backsplash and hardware before deciding.
Painting vs replacing cabinet doors at a glance
| What you want to change | Refinish existing fronts | Replace doors and drawer fronts |
|---|---|---|
| Colour and surface finish | Prepare and refinish the doors you already own. | Choose the finish for newly made fronts. |
| Door profile | Keep the existing shape and detailing. | Select a different profile for the new fronts. |
| Condition of the fronts | Assess existing surfaces and any repairs before pricing. | Replace the old fronts; inspect retained boxes and hardware separately. |
| Visible cabinet boxes | Include the required box finishing in the quote. | Include the required box finishing or coordinating treatment in the quote. |
| Best starting point | You like the current style and the fronts are suitable for refinishing. | You want a different style, or some fronts need replacement. |
Is a new door worth comparing with a refinishing quote?
The cost of refinishing is high enough that it is worth pricing both routes when the style is your main concern. Published Toronto service prices vary: Home Painters Pro advertises $150–$250 per cabinet door or drawer front, while Torr Handyman lists cabinet painting at $80–$150 per door.
Those figures describe different services and inclusions. They are advertised ranges reviewed on 1 October 2026, rather than quotations for your kitchen or a verified market average. Confirm the preparation, finish method, cabinet-box work, removal and reinstallation included in any price.
Painting or replacing cabinet doors: compare a 15″ × 30″ front
For comparison, these are Miter5’s current estimated prices for supplying a new 15″ × 30″ painted cabinet door:
| New door style | Estimated price per painted door, CAD |
|---|---|
| Aria — vertical-groove slab | $135.94 |
| Aurora — Shaker | $140.63 |
| Palmerston — thin Shaker | $159.38 |
| Euclid — architectural raised panel | $173.44 |
Miter5 examples calculated on 1 October 2026. These are supplied-door estimates, excluding taxes, delivery, hinge boring, installation, cabinet-box refinishing, special colours and other project-specific options. A painted order of 1–5 combined doors and drawer fronts adds one $75 small-order surcharge; orders of 6 or more pieces have no small-order surcharge. Sizes, quantities and specifications require review before production.
When a new profile is worth the difference
At this example size, a new painted Aria door at $135.94 or Aurora door at $140.63 is below the $150 starting point in Home Painters Pro’s advertised range. Palmerston at $159.38 and Euclid at $173.44 also fall within that $150–$250 range. Lower advertised refinishing rates exist, and the services include different work, so these figures are a reason to compare quotes rather than a calculation of total project savings.
If the existing profile is what makes your kitchen look outdated, price a new door style before paying to repaint the old one. Where the complete quotes are close, replacement can make more sense because your investment changes both the finish and the design. You can choose the vertical grooves of Aria, the straight-lined Shaker outline of Aurora, the narrow-frame thin Shaker profile of Palmerston or the defined panel of Euclid, rather than paying to preserve a profile you already want to change.
Use the Miter5 cabinet door collection and calculator to compare profiles using your actual sizes. Small fronts retain a minimum billable area of 1.5 sq. ft. per piece, so their price should not be estimated simply by multiplying their physical area by a rate.
Compare quotes for painting or replacing cabinet doors
A fair comparison puts the same kitchen and desired finish in front of both options. Ask for the work to be separated clearly:
- Refinishing: preparation and coating of the existing doors and drawer fronts, required repairs, box finishing, transport, removal and reinstallation.
- Replacement: new doors and drawer fronts, their specified finish, measurement and hardware requirements, box finishing, delivery and installation.
- For both: taxes, new hardware, visible end panels and trim, colour coordination and any exclusions.
Then compare what you will have when the work is complete. If a lower refinishing quote leaves you with a profile you already dislike, it may not meet the purpose of the update. If you love the existing fronts, replacement may add work and expense you do not need.
Your cabinet refinisher can still be part of the project
Replacing the doors can work alongside professional refinishing. A contractor can prepare and refinish suitable cabinet boxes while sourcing new fronts in the selected style. The homeowner gets a coordinated update, with the contractor managing the agreed finishing and installation work.
Miter5 manufactures made-to-order cabinet doors and drawer fronts for homeowners and trade customers. Unfinished, primed and painted options allow the door order to fit the project’s finishing plan. Confirm who supplies the finish, how the new fronts will coordinate with the boxes, and who is responsible for measurements and installation.
Agree on the finish and fitting before ordering
First, decide who will finish the new fronts. If your refinisher will coat them alongside the cabinet boxes, ask whether unfinished or primed supply suits their process. If you want painted doors supplied, agree on the colour and how the retained cabinet surfaces will coordinate. Two finishes with the same colour name can look different under kitchen lighting, so review a suitable sample with your contractor.
Next, confirm the door and drawer-front schedule before placing the order. A kitchen can contain several widths and heights, even when the fronts look similar at first glance. Your contractor should check the finished sizes, how the doors cover the cabinet openings and whether the chosen hinges will work. Changing hardware may affect the boring and fitting requirements.
Also, include the drawer fronts and any visible panels in the design discussion. Replacing only the doors can leave an old drawer profile beside a new one. A coordinated plan makes it easier to understand which surfaces will be replaced, which will be refinished and which will remain as they are.
Finally, agree on responsibilities in the written quote. Someone needs to check dimensions, approve the specifications, arrange delivery and fit the fronts. Miter5’s door estimate prices the supplied pieces; it does not replace your contractor’s quote for the rest of the kitchen. Confirm availability and the work sequence with both parties before scheduling the update.
Painting or replacing cabinet doors: choose the style you want
Refinish when the doors are suitable and you want to keep their style. Compare replacement when the shape, proportions or detailing are what make the kitchen feel out of date. If the cabinet boxes or layout also need substantial changes, assess the broader cabinetry work first.
For a kitchen with boxes worth retaining, new doors can give you a different design without starting again with the entire cabinet system. The next step is to choose a profile, confirm the required sizes and compare the complete scope.
See what a new door style would cost
Browse Miter5’s cabinet door styles and enter your finished sizes, quantities and preferred finish. Build an estimated door order to discuss with Miter5 and your refinishing or installation contractor.
Hero image: an illustrative comparison of door profiles, rather than a completed customer project. The four profile images show the Miter5 styles discussed above.



